Is Childhood Anxiety Robbing Kids of Their Innocence
APPLE PODCASTS | SPOTIFY | YOUTUBE
In today's fast-paced and technology-driven world, children are facing pressures unprecedented in history. Here we deep dive into the escalating anxieties plaguing our youngest generation. We connect the dots from Charles Dickens' 19th-century observations on child labor to the modern-day phenomena that see children treated as mini-adults, burdened by expectations and robbed of their innocence.
Subscribe on Patreon for just $2
Unlock early access to shows and exclusive merch with our Patreon. Become a Humanity Archiver today.
Our journey through this landscape seeks to unravel how, despite centuries of progress, the essence of childhood vulnerability remains constant. Here’s what we cover":
The Dickensian Parallel
Historical Insights: Charles Dickens famously shed light on the grim realities of child labor during the 19th century, sparking social reform. We explore how this historical lens offers perspective on today's children, who, while not in factories, face their own forms of labor through relentless academic and social pressures.
Lost Innocence: The conversation probes the critical question: Are we stripping our children of their childhoods by imposing adult-like responsibilities and expectations on them?
Technological Ties That Bind
A Double-Edged Sword: The technological revolution has transformed the way children connect with the world. While offering unprecedented access to information and social networks, it also isolates them and subjects them to constant evaluation, contributing to rising levels of anxiety and depression.
The Culture of Comparison: The impact of social media and digital platforms in fostering a culture of comparison and constant scrutiny is scrutinized, underlining its role in the anxiety epidemic among children.
Society's Role in Child Anxiety
Metaphorical Consumption: The discussion delves into the metaphorical aspect of society 'devouring' its youth, placing intolerable pressures on them, leading to an increase in anxiety and stress.
Anxiety vs. Fear: A clear distinction is drawn between anxiety and fear, highlighting how the former, fueled by uncertainty and "what-ifs," places an unbearable load on children, affecting their mental and emotional well-being.
Pathways to a Healthier Childhood
Prioritizing Mental Health: The urgent need to prioritize children's mental and emotional health is emphasized, suggesting practical steps to alleviate the pressures they face.
Envisioning a Less Anxious Future: The conversation concludes with a call to action, urging society, parents, educators, and policymakers to work towards creating an environment where children can grow and learn free from the excessive stresses that lead to anxiety and depression.
This isn’t just a reflection on the increasing burdens of childhood anxiety but a clarion call to recognize and address the myriad factors contributing to it. By drawing parallels with the past and examining the impact of modern society and technology, we underscore the importance of safeguarding our children's mental health and ensuring they have the freedom and support to enjoy their childhood, free from the shadows of anxiety and depression.
RESEARCH & RESOURCES:
Saturn Devouring his Son (1819-23) by Goya, www.visual-arts-cork.com, n.d
-
Let me take you back to the year 1842. Charles Dickens, the great English writer, visited a coal mine known as a dark satanic mill. He was horrified by what he saw children. Some as young as six were working in unimaginable conditions, their faces blackened by coal, their eyes sullen and sunken into their faces, their spirits crushed by the weight of adult responsibilities.
Dickens was so moved by this experience that he went on to write some of the most socially impactful literature of his time, shedding light on the plight of children in the industrial age. His stories weren't just stories. They were a call to action, a plea for societal change. Now you might be wondering what about Dickens observations from nearly two centuries ago have anything to do with our lives today? Well, stick with me here because I found myself in a modern day mind of sorts.
And this whole show came about because I was in the grocery store the other day passing by other shoppers. And sometimes it's in these random moments that my brain starts going deep, you know, like a toy aisle, revealing the immense pressures we're putting on our kids. And so I'm standing there, right? And these toys, the Hot Wheels, the Mr. Potato heads, the Simon Says is there like time capsules. They take me back to a time when life was just about Saturday morning cartoons and
deciding which action figure was gonna save the day. That aisle was like a little sanctuary of innocence in the middle of all this adult chaos, you know? And I felt at home for a second. But then I look over and I see fidget toys and stress balls and these weird squishy unicorn things. And I'm thinking, what is going on here? Why are we making stress relief toys for kids? It's like we've got this epidemic of stress and anxiety, not just for adults, but also for our kids too.
I mean, depression and anxiety are like the top mental health issues globally. And what's that about? Why are we passing this culture of stress down to the next generation? So just as Dickens observed children burdened by adult responsibilities and minds, our children today are burdened as well, but just in a different way. They're not in coal mines, but they're navigating a culture obsessed with student achievement, still obsessed with work. There are laws being passed right now to loosen.
laws to put kids back to work in several states in America. They're being bombarded with electronic stimulus and expectations, leaving them tired and feeling very inadequate and feeling very alone. Now think about it, we've got this technological revolution that's been a double -edged sword. On the one hand, we're more connected than ever. On the other, we're isolating ourselves, even our kids in this digital realm. It's like we've fast -tracked them into a world of
Constant evaluation, likes and dislikes, swipes left and right, and we wonder why they're stressed. And I thought about all this and it calls me to question, are we treating our kids too much like adults still? Are we robbing them of the innocence and freedom that should define childhood? Are we setting them up for a lifetime of stress and anxiety by pushing them into this adult -sized world way too soon? And most importantly, if we continue down this path, what's the future going to look like? A generation of burnt out, stressed out adults.
never really got to be kids. And let me give you an example of what it looks like for society to devour its youth. Francisco de Goya, a man who lived through the Spanish Inquisition, the Peninsular War and all the political turmoil that came with it was like this rock star of the Spanish art scene from the late 18th to the early 19th century. But let's not forget this guy went dark, really dark with his so -called
black paintings is what they're called when you look at them historically. And that's how people write about them because they were really dark. And one of those paintings was of Saturn devouring his son. This is stuff of nightmares. Now imagine this, you walk into a dimly lit room and there it is Saturn, his eyes are bulging, consumed by a kind of madness that's almost palpable. He's clutching his child who's already half eaten.
And you can almost hear the crotch feel the wetness of the blood. It's like a scene from a horror movie, but it's not. It's a painting on a wall. You can look it up and you're standing there asking yourself what kind of mind comes up with this, but let's dig deeper because this isn't just gore for the sake of gore. This is rooted in mythology. It's rooted in history. Saturn or Cronus in Greek mythology was told one of his children would overthrow him. So what does he do? He eats him.
The story is old as time, a tale of a parent so consumed by his own fears and insecurities that he literally devours his offspring. Now hold on a minute, this is an archetypal story. It's a cautionary tale warning us about the destructive power of consuming fear and the lengths people will go to maintain control. It's not just about a God eating his kid. It's about the destructive tendencies that we all have within us, especially.
when it comes to wielding power over the vulnerable. So when we look at this painting, we're not just seeing a gruesome act, we're seeing a mirror reflecting our own society's willingness to sacrifice the young for the sake of preserving the status quo. We're not talking literal flesh eating here, but aren't we metaphorically devouring our youth's mental and emotional well -being? The Goya painting, right? It's...
Like a gut punch to the soul. It's not just a visceral haunting image. It's a metaphor for how we as a society are willing to consume our young, not with teeth, but with expectations and pressures and anxieties. It's like we're Saturn and our own kids are the ones who are getting devoured. And I think it's important to distinguish the difference between anxiety and fear. Fear is that primal guttural response to immediate danger. I've done a lot of work on Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., a man whose home was bombed and is beaten.
threatened face real tangible threats every day. So an evolutionary response to these real threats would be fear. And we can come up with countless examples. The King example just came to mind from a previous show that I did, but now we can trust anxiety. It's like the insidious cousin of fear. It's not about the lion in the grass. It's about the possibility of a lion in every patch of grass, everywhere, forever. Anxiety is about the unknown, the what ifs, the...
catastrophes that haven't happened but could. It's like we're living in a world that's a minefield of potential disasters and we're handing our kids the map without teaching them how to navigate it. So there's another quote by a Corey Tinboom. She was a Dutch watchmaker who lived through the horrors of World War II and she once said, quote, worrying is carrying tomorrow's load with today's strength, carrying two days at once. That one really hit me. It's like we're burdening.
Our kids with the worries of a world they're not equipped to handle. And let's not forget the statistics for youths ages 10 to 14 suicide as a second leading cause of death. So let's get real here. Many of you have kids and if you don't, we were all once kids. And so how many kids out there or how many of you have felt as kids and then carry that into your adulthood, the cycle of tear, of anxiety, of stress, the answer is millions. And that's not just a number.
These are individual lives and people just like you and I, each one grappling with their own set of fears and anxieties on the daily. And so now we make it to the modern world. And so there are now millions of kids within this generation who grew up who know nothing but technology. They didn't grow up without technology like I did. And so that's a double edged sword. Technology is filling the world with more opportunities and advancements, but on the other hand, it's a pressure cooker.
of expectations, of judgments. And so now you have the statistics showing that nearly one in three of all adolescents between the ages of 13 and 18 experiencing an anxiety disorder, kids struggling with depression at alarming rate, falling prey to a society that values success over happiness, achievement over contentment. And so what do we do? I think we've got to love our children.
enough to let them be children. We've got to be the wind at their backs, not the hand at their throats. We can be the generation that says enough is enough and starts to turn the tide. We can model compassion beginning today and show the youth that there are ways to cope and strive for a better world with less calls for anxiety. And we can let this be the generation that changes the narrative, that redraws the painting, that changes history, that slays the dragon of anxiety and lets our children breathe.